Sunday, 4 October 2026

Difference between RCSI and Snapshot Isolation

 RCSI provides statement-level consistent reads with minimal blocking and no application changes, while Snapshot Isolation provides transaction-level consistency using the same row versioning infrastructure but adds update conflict detection and guarantees a stable point-in-time view throughout the transaction.

Feature

RCSI (Read Committed Snapshot Isolation)

Snapshot Isolation (SI)

Isolation Level

Modified READ COMMITTED

Separate Isolation Level

Introduced In

SQL Server 2005

SQL Server 2005

Uses Row Versioning

Yes

Yes

Uses TempDB Version Store

Yes

Yes

Prevents Dirty Reads

Yes

Yes

Reader Blocks Writer

No (mostly)

No (mostly)

Writer Blocks Reader

No (mostly)

No (mostly)

Shared Locks for Reads

Not required for data reads

Not required for data reads

Consistency Scope

Statement Level

Transaction Level

Snapshot Taken When

At the start of each statement

At the start of transaction

Data Seen by SELECT

Latest committed data when statement starts

Data as of transaction start

Multiple SELECTs in Same Transaction

Can see different committed data

Always see same version

Repeatable Reads Guaranteed?

No

Yes

Phantom Reads Possible?

Yes (between statements)

No

Non-Repeatable Reads Possible?

Yes (between statements)

No

Update Conflict Detection

No

Yes

Error 3960 Possible?

No

Yes

Application Code Changes Required

No

Yes

SET TRANSACTION ISOLATION LEVEL Needed

No

Yes

Enable at Database Level

Yes

Yes

Suitable for Existing Applications

Excellent

Requires code changes

Reporting Consistency

Medium

High

Long Running Transactions

Not ideal for consistent reporting

Excellent

Concurrency

Very High

High

TempDB Usage

High

High

Version Store Usage

High

High

Most Commonly Used

Yes

Less Common

Typical Use Case

OLTP Systems

Financial Reporting / Auditing

No comments:

Post a Comment

If you have any doubt, please let me know.

Popular Posts